With the winter meetings underway, it’s time to talk a little Rule 5 draft. The draft is on Thursday and they’ll be picking 18th, possibly earlier, as some teams already have a full roster. Before we talk about the who’s who in the draft, here’s a quick refresher on how it works-
- If a player is 18 years old or younger on the June 5 preceding the player’s original signing date, that player is subject to selection at the fifth Rule 5 Draft following the player’s original contract if not added to the 40 man roster.
- If a player is 19 years old or older on the June 5 preceding the player’s original signing date, the player is subject to selection at the fourth Rule 5 Draft following the player’s original contract if not added to the 40 man roster.
Most commonly, high school players signed in ’04 and college players signed in ’05 are eligible for the Rule 5 draft for the first time this year. Depending on the timing of their signing, some international players originally signed in ’04 are also eligible.
If a team selects a player in the major league portion of Rule 5, the selecting team must pay the original team $50K and they must keep the player on their 25 man roster for the entire season. The player must also be on the active roster for 90 days, so there is no drafting a player and then hiding them on the 60 day DL all year. If a team decides at any time during the season that they don’t want the player, the player must clear waivers first, and then be offered back to the original team for $25K, 1/2 the original cost. If the player is claimed on waivers or traded, the Rule 5 obligation passes to his new team.
We already discussed this earlier, but here again are the Cardinal players available for the Rule 5 draft:
RHP Mark McCormick
RHP Luis Perdomo
OF Cody Haerther
RHP Kenny Maiques
RHP Trey Hearne
RHP Elvis Hernandez
RHP Mike Sillman
RHP Mike Parisi (just coming off Tommy John)
C Brandon Yarbrough
UTIL Casey Rowlett
C Matt Pagnozzi
OF Christofher Dumont
LHP Ian Ostlund
C Justin Knoedler
Out of these players, McCormick and Perdomo are the most attractive to other clubs.
On to the LOOGers. We know the club would like another lefty reliever, one who can not only LOOGY it up, but also work in some mop up duty. There are several players that might fit that bill-
- Donald Veal, Cubs: There’s a fair chance he will go early. Veal has an arm scouts swoon over, and also some nifty numbers against lefties–8.45 K/9, 46% groundball rate. The problem is Veal doesn’t know where his pitches are going most of the time, and if he knew how to do something about it, he would’ve by now. The Cubs are done trying to fix him, but if he can be salvaged, there’s some big upside to be had here.
- Chuck Lofgren, Indians: Once considered a top prospect in the Tribe’s system, Lofgren has fallen apart. He doesn’t really profile as a LOOGY, but more of a swing man with upside to become a solid starter. Lofgren has four pitches, and when he is right he’s mixing speeds and location at will. Lofgren is only 22, so there’s still hope he can correct his mechanical and mental issues.
- Jose Lugo, Twins: Lugo is only coming off a full season in the Florida State League, but has the extreme ground ball tendencies that make Dave Duncan’s heart go a pitter-patter. Lugo is known for a heavy sinker he throws in the low to mid-nineties, and he struck out 9.2 batters per nine with a 57.3% groundball rate.
- Brad Kilby, A’s: Probably a safer bet then the aforementioned players with nothing much else to prove in the minors. Kilby throws 88-91 with a decent slider and a change. Last season for Sacramento, Kilby held lefties to a .183 average, and for his career he’s struck out more than a batter per inning throughout his career. On the downside, last year at least, he was about as an extreme fly ball pitch you could find. He’ll be 26 in February.
- Zachary Kroenke, Yankees: His slider is his only plus pitch and he is labeled as a “pie thrower”, which has to be one of my favorite scouting terms. A pie thrower is defined by BA as “a pitcher who, while throwing a pitch, holds his palm too far under the ball rather than having his fingers on top of it, as if throwing a pie.” You can check him out for yourself here. He struck out over 10 per nine innings and held left-handed batters to a .213 average.
- Chris Blazek, Astros: Known as an aggressive pitcher, Blazek struck out nearly a third of the batter’s he faced in AA last year. He was shut down with elbow soreness after just one inning in the AFL, so there’s a red flag.
Other names of note: Kyle Bloom, Ryan Mullins, Kei Igawa.

Entries (RSS)
You gotta figure were going to draft one of these guys. While i think Veal is the best option it is almost certain that he will go before we have an opportunity to pick. I haven’t heard of Jose Lugo before now but having now researched him a little bit I believe he is the most likely for us to draft.
i wouldn’t mind taking a flier on lofgren…..that is if he’s still available.
I wouldn’t be surprised at all to see the Cardinals take one of these guys, especially with the roster space they have right now. Also, I wouldn’t be shocked to see the Cardinals grab a middle infielder with their pick instead, since it seems like the most likely candidates to take over a major league role as a starter are in AA or lower (like Solano, Kozma, Vasquez, and Castillo).
I think we would be well served to take a chance on one of these guys. Any 2B to the tune of Uggla in this year’s rule 5?
@ PJ–No power hitting middle infielders in this rule 5. The middle infielders are more of your defense first, slap and dash types. The ones I know of are Daniel Mayora, Justin Sellers, Hainley Statia, Corey Wimberly and Will Rhymes. None are probably a whole lot better than what we have now.
It doesn’t seem like we are going to have a new second baseman next year anyways. We’ve been hearing for a while that Kennedy might stay, now after his comments in the new article in the post it is almost certain he will be back.
Regarding the List of Cardinals available –
If one or more of those are on the list of players
offered to the Padres as the PTBN for Khalil Greene,
then what happens?
Aren’t those PTBN players NOT available for the Rule 5?
That’s my understanding.
But I’ve been wrong before!
what about that viola guy in the reds system..he’s seems legit
You forgot that lefty out of the Twins system. I think Mullins is his last name. 6’6″ with great numbers for a LOOGY.
I think you mean Jaime Garcia is just coming off Tommy John or did I miss something about Parisi?
Parisi also will require TJ this offseason.
Here are a couple of suggestions to get younger and better. Trade Kennedy, Duncan, Anderson & Ottanvino or similar package to the Giants for Sanchez & Velez. You get a good young pitcher and second baseman plus they are controlled for a number of years.
Trade Schumacher to Toronto for one of their lefties. Then spend the last 15 million on Fuentes for 2 years plus a vesting year!
I think choosing Corey Wimberly would be the best choice in the rule 5 draft for the club.He is a steal, plays alot like Ozzie and steals bases in his sleep.Besides we would love to see another Jacksonville native running around the bases in a Cards uniform just like Vince Coleman.Corey Wimberly is the real deal he has the heart of a tiger, and the speed of a Jaguar!!!!!!