So far your results are looking an awfully lot like ours. Is that the confirmation bias, or are these more obvious then I thought? It should get trickier from here. Consider some of the other top tens. Baseball Digest Daily has compiled all the rankings into one handy spreadsheet, click over to the NL Central and see what I’m talking about.
The first three or four are all about the same, but after that, the rankings diverge greatly. Some players that are top ten prospects on one list don’t make the cut, for example Jess Todd is # 4 on BA’s list and he doesn’t crack Keith Law’s. OTOH, Keith has Niko Vasquez and Francisco Samuel on his list. Kevin Goldstein has Adam Reifer. BA and our list are the only ones to have David Freese. That’s a lot of disparity.
Here’s what we have so far. Vote now for #7.